ABA Tax Section - Recap

One piece of advice: If you are not a member of the ABA Tax Section then join! If you are a member of the ABA Tax Section then try to attend at least one of the conferences held throughout the year. This year I was fortunate to be part of a panel that presented to the Young Lawyer’s section a Q&A on IDR’s.

Christopher M. Pietruszkiewicz a law professor at LSU was the mediator and Joshua Odintz, from the Senate Finance committee, was the co-presenter. They were both excellent. What we tried to communicate to the young lawyers is that IDR’s should not be viewed as a one-way street in favor of the IRS but a communication channel that allows the taxpayer to understand and narrow the IRS’s position.

Yes, under § 6001 a taxpayer is required to maintain books and records to support the position claimed on the income tax return, which the IRS and tax litigators realize is an admission as to one’s interest. An IDR should be responded in a similar fashion as it is written – If the IRS asks for an item in general terms then respond accordingly. The next IDR written by the IRS will be more focused and tailored to the information that the IRS is truly seeking. In turn, this helps the taxpayer identify and understand the true issue at hand. For the process to works correctly, the taxpayer’s representative needs to research and understand the tax position at issue. More important the representative needs to learn how to communicate with his/her counterpart. Other wise the process will fail that means communication has failed and thus the process may evolve into a contentious matter.

This is not to say that the taxpayer should just turn over all records to the IRS. We are lawyers and have a responsibility to our clients. Therefore as tax litigators, we must not only know the code but must be fully aware of the privileges that our respective clients have, attorney-client. And don’t forget our own privilege - the work-product doctrine. Can we say – Textron. And to the criminal defense attorney who did not understand how IDR’s work, yes we understood the dangers of interviews just see United States v. Stein.

I was fortunate to take in as much of FIN 48 as one could possibly take in. To my astonishment, the individual who educated me the most was not a name partner nor a government tax litigator but an associate –Diana Wollman from Sullivan & Cromwell. She and her colleagues, including a certain former acting chief counsel Emily Parker, did a tremendous job in their presentation- “Transactional Tax in a FIN 48 world”. The points they addressed were extremely insightful With the 12 month projection will the IRS demand additional adjustments? Will the IRS require settlements to reflect the reserves? The specific table of issues detail – how much and how does the detail or lack thereof impact resolutions?

In an earlier presentation “FIN 48 – Impact on Litigation and Settlements”, the government official made it clear that FIN 48 workpapers and tax accrual workpapers are viewed by the government as one and the same. As such the same procedures that apply for a request for tax accrual workpapers apply to FIN 48 workpapers. So check out the Q&A on the IRS’s website to determine when the workpapers will be requested. Hint: Think tax avoidance transactions. For potential mergers, Wollman’s panel brought out the problems that can arise when a company acquires/mergers with another company an shelters are involved.

Finally there was the Civil and Criminal Tax Penalties presentation with an update on “Economic Substance Doctrine in the Prosecution and Defense of a Criminal Tax Case”. “Interestingly”, the parties disagreed on whether there had to be a uniform instruction to the jury as to economic substance. I tend to agree with the private practitioners – how can a defendant be convicted of a crime if the crime can not be properly defined? But, credit to the government official for finally admitting why KPMG was left of the hook – pure business as big business could not afford another Arthur Anderson. Observation for the government: What a heavy price - our constitutional rights.

Again I find these presentations to be educating while stimulating and encourage everyone to come out next time.


The individual who maintains this Blog works at Fox Rothschild LLP. The information, comments, and links posted on this Blog do not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship has been or will be formed by any communication(s) to, from or with the Blog and/or the Blogger. For legal advice, contact an attorney at Fox Rothschild LLP or an attorney actively practicing in your jurisdiction. Do not send any confidential or priviliged information to the Blogger; neither Fox Rothschild LLP nor the Blogger will assume any liability or responsibility for it. If you send any information, documents or materials to the Blog, you give permission for the Blogger to include them on or in the Blog. No information, documents or materials you send to the Blog will be considered confidential or priviliged by Fox Rothschild LLP or its lawyers. Also, no such information, documents or materials will be returned to you. All decisions relating to the content of the Blog belong to the Blogger.

Privacy Policy

The publishing lawyer and law firm values the privacy of its clients and Web/blog site viewers. Any of the following personal information that may be made available to the lawyer or firm when browsing or navigating the site shall be kept confidential:

  • First and last name
  • Company, home, postal or other physical address
  • Other contact information, for example, telephone number, fax number, email address, and other similar information
  • Title or position in a company or an organization
  • Occupation
  • Industry
  • Personal interests
  • Any other information needed to provide a service you requested

Examples of scenarios where our visitors provide their personal information include, but may not be limited, to:

  • Emailing, calling or communicating with the lawyer or law firm.
  • Posting a question or comment through the site.
  • Requesting literature.
  • Registering to attend a seminar or any event.
  • Participating in an online survey.
  • Requesting inclusion in an email or other mailing list.
  • Submitting an entry for a contest or other promotions.
  • Logging in to the site, thus requiring a user name and/or a password.
  • Any other business-related reason.

The lawyer or law firm provides you the opportunity to agree or decline to give your personal information via the Internet. The lawyer or firm will inform you of the purpose for the collection and does not intend to transfer your personal information to third parties without your consent, except under the limited conditions described under the discussion entitled “Information Sharing and Disclosure” below. If you choose to provide us with your personal information, we may transfer that information, within the law firm or to a third party service provider as necessary.

Domain Information Collection

The lawyer or firm may collect domain information to enable us to analyze how our visitors use this site. This data enables us to become more familiar with which people visit our site, how often they visit, and what parts of the site they visit most often. The lawyer or firm uses this information to improve its Web-based offerings. This information is collected automatically and requires no action on your part.

Use of Cookies and Tracking User Traffic

Some pages on this site may use “cookies”—small files that the site places on your hard drive for identification purposes. A cookie file can contain information such as a user ID to track the pages visited, but the only personal information a cookie can contain is information you supply yourself. These files are used for site registration and customization the next time you visit us.

Some parts of the site may also use cookies to track user traffic patterns. The lawyer or firm does this in order to determine the usefulness of our Web site information to our users and to see how effective our navigational structure is in helping users reach that information. Please note that cookies cannot read data off of your hard drive. Your Web browser may allow you to be notified when you are receiving a cookie, giving you the choice to accept it or not. If you prefer not to receive cookies while browsing our Web site, you can set your browser to warn you before accepting cookies and refuse the cookie when your browser alerts you to its presence. You can also refuse all cookies by turning them off in your browser, By not accepting cookies, some pages may not fully function and you may not be able to access certain information on this site.

Information Sharing and Disclosure

Your personal information is never shared outside the lawyer or firm without your permission, except under conditions listed below:

  • Consenting to share your information to a third party service provider working on our behalf to serve you.
  • Requiring us to provide you with a product or service.

The lawyer or firm will also disclose your personal information, if required to do so by law, or in urgent circumstances, to protect personal safety, the public or our sites.

Internet Security

The lawyer or firm strives to protect your personal information; however, we urge you to take every precaution to protect your personal data when you are on the Internet. Change your passwords often, use a combination of letters

Protecting the Privacy of Children

Children under 13 years old are not the target audience for our Web site. To protect their privacy, the lawyer or firm prohibits the solicitation of personal information from these children.

Links to Third Party Sites

This site may contain links to other sites. The lawyer or firm does not share your personal information with those Web sites and is not responsible for their privacy practices. We encourage you to learn about the privacy policies of those companies.

Changes to this Privacy Policy

The lawyer or firm reserves the right to change, modify or update this policy at any time without notice. Any substantial changes in the way we use your personal information will be posted on this site.

If you have questions or concerns about our Privacy Policy, please email us at the contact information on the site.